"Updating" all state in redux app properly - javascript

I've met some trouble assigning a new object in the reducer of my app. My state contains 2 arrays :
{
elements: [],
constraints: []
}
Those elements are handled by 2 reducers :
elementsReducer
constraintsReducer
and combined like this:
let reducer = combineReducers({
elements: elementsReducer,
constraints: constraintsReducer
});
export default reducer
So, basically, an action is triggered, and my reducer is supposed to update all the state.elements array. I've tried several things and I can't update the whole elements array, only - in the best case - the first element.
My first idea was to do:
return Object.assign({}, state, {
elements: state.map((e) => {
return Object.assign({}, e, {
text: action.data[e.id][e.text]
})
})
});
action.data is an array containing a different text for each element. Basically, all I was to do is, on a special action, updating all the element array. But this syntax does not work as it creates a new array INSIDE the array "elements" of the store. It does not replace it. If I let this, the store becomes:
{
elements: [
elements: [...]
],
constraints: [...]
}
When I access the state in my reducer elementsReducer, it's only the "element" array and not the full state. After this issue, I've tried to do the following:
return state.map(function(e) {
return assign({}, e, {
text: action.data[e.id][e.text]
});
});
Now, I worked, but the ONLY element mapped is the first one. The other elements are simply not updating.
Do you have any idea to solve the issue?
Thanks everyone :)
Xelys
EDIT :
// code of elementsReducer
var assign = require('object-assign');
export default function elementsReducer(state = {}, action) {
switch (action.type) {
case 'ADD_ELEMENT':
return [...state,
{
name: action.name,
id: action.id,
committed: false,
text: action.text
}
]
case 'COMMIT_ELEMENT':
console.log('commit action')
return state.map(function(e) {
return e.id === action.id ?
assign({}, e, {committed: true}) :
e
});
case 'SAVE_DATA':
return state.map((e) => {
return Object.assign({}, e, {
text: action.data[e.id][e.text]
});
});
default:
return state;
}
}


Based on your code, I assumed your data structure is like below:
// state.element
stateElement = [
{ id:1, text: '1t' },
{ id:2, text: '2t' }
];
// Your action result
action = {
data: {
1: { text: 'new 1t' },
2: { text: 'new 2t' }
}
}
// Your new state.element
newData = data.map(function(e) {
return Object.assign({}, e, {
text: action.data[e.id].text
});
});


thanks for the answers.
#Ali Sepehri.Kh, yeah, my data structure is very similar. Actually, it's a little bit more complex, but I've simplified it to be more understable.
However, I figured out to solve the issue. I feel quite ashamed of creating a post on stackoverflow, because the error had nothing to do with redux.
The mapping function I've used was totally working. The issue was located is the action data. The function which created the action.data array was returning an array empty after the first element. I thought the issue was coming from the map() as it was for me the "most difficult" part of the fonction.
However, I've made a stupid mistake on the fonction creating the array of the action. I have misplaced a "return" inside a for loop, which explain that all the elements after the first one were empty.
Sorry for your time guys, and thanks for the help :).

Related

What is the most comfortable/conventional way to modify a specific item in an array, in a React component state?

I often find my self struggling with manipulating a specific item in an array, in a React component state. For example:
state={
menus:[
{
id:1,
title: 'something',
'subtitle': 'another something',
switchOn: false
},
{
id:2,
title: 'something else',
'subtitle': 'another something else',
switchOn: false
},
]
}
This array is filled with objects, that have various properties. One of those properties is of course a unique ID. This is what i have done recentely to edit a "switchOn" property on an item, according to its ID:
handleSwitchChange = (id) => {
const newMenusArray = this.state.menus.map((menu) => {
if (menu.id === id) {
return {
...menu,
switchOn: !menu.switchOn
};
} else {
return menu;
};
})
this.setState(()=>{
return{
menus: newMenusArray
}
})
}
As you can see, alot of trouble, just to change one value. In AngularJS(1), i would just use the fact that objects are passed by reference, and would directly mutate it, without any ES6 hustle.
Is it possible i'm missing something, and there is a much more straightforward approach for dealing with this? Any example would be greatly appreciated.

A good way is to make yourself a indexed map. Like you might know it from databases, they do not iterate over all entries, but are using indexes. Indexes are just a way of saying ID A points to Object Where ID is A
So what I am doing is, building a indexed map with e.g. a reducer
const map = data.reduce((map, item) => {
map[item.id] = item;
return map;
}, {})
now you can access your item by ID simply by saying
map[myId]
If you want to change it, you can use than object assign, or the ... syntax
return {
// copy all map if you want it to be immutable
...map
// override your object
[id]: {
// copy it first
...map[id],
// override what you want
switchOn: !map[id].switchOn
}
}
As an helper library, I could suggest you use Immutable.js, where you just change the value as it were a reference

I usually use findIndex
handleSwitchChange = (id) => {
var index = this.state.menu.findIndex((item) => {
return item.id === id;
});
if (index === -1) {
return;
}
let newMenu = this.state.menu.slice();
newMenu[index].switchOn = !this.state.menu[index].switchOn;
this.setState({
menu: newMenu
});
}

Revert changes to array in Vue

I'm trying to have a component which can change some elements in it. In reality, a change will be like swapping the object in a given position. I did some POC and tried to do the reverting method to be able to leave it how it was before.
export default {
name: 'Landing',
data () {
return {
items: [
{
id: 1,
category: 'Something something'
},
{
id: 2,
category: 'Something something'
}
]
};
},
created() {
this.originals = this.items.slice(0);
},
methods: {
change() {
this.items[0].category = 'Changed';
},
revert() {
// ??
}
}
};
I've tried a couple of things especially after reading this: https://vuejs.org/2016/02/06/common-gotchas/#Why-isn%E2%80%99t-the-DOM-updating
while (this.snacks.length) {
this.items.pop();
}
this.originals.slice(0).forEach(o => this.items.push(o));
But it doesn't work. If I delete the pushing part, I get an empty list correctly but if I try somehow to push it back, it won't work.
What am I missing here?

If you give a working fiddle I can show you what happened.
Basically, because you are modifying the same array object. this.originals refers to the same array as this.items
Slice returns a shallow copy of the object. You should either take a deep copy or your revert should be the one initializing the object.
this.items.pop();
will remove the items from this.originals as well.

Iterate over array and change a certain property using Immunity Helper for a Redux Reducer

I'm trying to learn Immunity Helper as I think it would help me with my Reducers but I can't figure out how to change a property in all the objects of an array.
Any help please, I been stuck for so long
https://github.com/kolodny/immutability-helper
https://facebook.github.io/react/docs/update.html
my initial state
outputList: [
{ propertyIWantToChange: 'some value1' },
{ propertyIWantToChange: 'some value2' },
{ propertyIWantToChange: 'some value3' }, etc
]
Reducer that does not work. I feel like my syntax is just off a bit but I can't figure out which part.
case types.SOME_TYPE: {
return update(state, {
outputList: {
propertyIWantToChange: {$set: action.value}
}
});

You would have to iterate over that array. If that list accepts map then something like this should work, I guess:
case types.SOME_TYPE: {
const lst = state.outputList.map((el) => {
return update(el, { propertyIwantToChange: {$set: action.value}}
});
return update(state, { outputList: {$set: lst}})
}

How to update single value inside specific array item in redux

I have an issue where re-rendering of state causes ui issues and was suggested to only update specific value inside my reducer to reduce amount of re-rendering on a page.
this is example of my state
{
name: "some name",
subtitle: "some subtitle",
contents: [
{title: "some title", text: "some text"},
{title: "some other title", text: "some other text"}
]
}
and I am currently updating it like this
case 'SOME_ACTION':
return { ...state, contents: action.payload }
where action.payload is a whole array containing new values. But now I actually just need to update text of second item in contents array, and something like this doesn't work
case 'SOME_ACTION':
return { ...state, contents[1].text: action.payload }
where action.payload is now a text I need for update.

You can use map. Here is an example implementation:
case 'SOME_ACTION':
return {
...state,
contents: state.contents.map(
(content, i) => i === 1 ? {...content, text: action.payload}
: content
)
}

You could use the React Immutability helpers
import update from 'react-addons-update';
// ...
case 'SOME_ACTION':
return update(state, {
contents: {
1: {
text: {$set: action.payload}
}
}
});
Although I would imagine you'd probably be doing something more like this?
case 'SOME_ACTION':
return update(state, {
contents: {
[action.id]: {
text: {$set: action.payload}
}
}
});

Very late to the party but here is a generic solution that works with every index value.
You create and spread a new array from the old array up to the index you want to change.
Add the data you want.
Create and spread a new array from the index you wanted to change to the end of the array
let index=1;// probably action.payload.id
case 'SOME_ACTION':
return {
...state,
contents: [
...state.contents.slice(0,index),
{title: "some other title", text: "some other text"},
...state.contents.slice(index+1)
]
}
Update:
I have made a small module to simplify the code, so you just need to call a function:
case 'SOME_ACTION':
return {
...state,
contents: insertIntoArray(state.contents,index, {title: "some title", text: "some text"})
}
For more examples, take a look at the repository
function signature:
insertIntoArray(originalArray,insertionIndex,newData)
Edit:
There is also Immer.js library which works with all kinds of values, and they can also be deeply nested.

You don't have to do everything in one line:
case 'SOME_ACTION': {
const newState = { ...state };
newState.contents =
[
newState.contents[0],
{title: newState.contents[1].title, text: action.payload}
];
return newState
};

I believe when you need this kinds of operations on your Redux state the spread operator is your friend and this principal applies for all children.
Let's pretend this is your state:
const state = {
houses: {
gryffindor: {
points: 15
},
ravenclaw: {
points: 18
},
hufflepuff: {
points: 7
},
slytherin: {
points: 5
}
}
}
And you want to add 3 points to Ravenclaw
const key = "ravenclaw";
return {
...state, // copy state
houses: {
...state.houses, // copy houses
[key]: { // update one specific house (using Computed Property syntax)
...state.houses[key], // copy that specific house's properties
points: state.houses[key].points + 3 // update its `points` property
}
}
}
By using the spread operator you can update only the new state leaving everything else intact.
Example taken from this amazing article, you can find almost every possible option with great examples.

This is remarkably easy in redux-toolkit, it uses Immer to help you write immutable code that looks like mutable which is more concise and easier to read.
// it looks like the state is mutated, but under the hood Immer keeps track of
// every changes and create a new state for you
state.x = newValue;
So instead of having to use spread operator in normal redux reducer
return {
...state,
contents: state.contents.map(
(content, i) => i === 1 ? {...content, text: action.payload}
: content
)
}
You can simply reassign the local value and let Immer handle the rest for you:
state.contents[1].text = action.payload;
Live Demo

In my case I did something like this, based on Luis's answer:
// ...State object...
userInfo = {
name: '...',
...
}
// ...Reducer's code...
case CHANGED_INFO:
return {
...state,
userInfo: {
...state.userInfo,
// I'm sending the arguments like this: changeInfo({ id: e.target.id, value: e.target.value }) and use them as below in reducer!
[action.data.id]: action.data.value,
},
};

Immer.js (an amazing react/rn/redux friendly package) solves this very efficiently. A redux store is made up of immutable data - immer allows you to update the stored data cleanly coding as though the data were not immutable.
Here is the example from their documentation for redux:
(Notice the produce() wrapped around the method. That's really the only change in your reducer setup.)
import produce from "immer"
// Reducer with initial state
const INITIAL_STATE = [
/* bunch of todos */
]
const todosReducer = produce((draft, action) => {
switch (action.type) {
case "toggle":
const todo = draft.find(todo => todo.id === action.id)
todo.done = !todo.done
break
case "add":
draft.push({
id: action.id,
title: "A new todo",
done: false
})
break
default:
break
}
})
(Someone else mentioned immer as a side effect of redux-toolkit, but you should use immer directly in your reducer.)
Immer installation:
https://immerjs.github.io/immer/installation

This is how I did it for one of my projects:
const markdownSaveActionCreator = (newMarkdownLocation, newMarkdownToSave) => ({
type: MARKDOWN_SAVE,
saveLocation: newMarkdownLocation,
savedMarkdownInLocation: newMarkdownToSave
});
const markdownSaveReducer = (state = MARKDOWN_SAVED_ARRAY_DEFAULT, action) => {
let objTemp = {
saveLocation: action.saveLocation,
savedMarkdownInLocation: action.savedMarkdownInLocation
};
switch(action.type) {
case MARKDOWN_SAVE:
return(
state.map(i => {
if (i.saveLocation === objTemp.saveLocation) {
return Object.assign({}, i, objTemp);
}
return i;
})
);
default:
return state;
}
};

I'm afraid that using map() method of an array may be expensive since entire array is to be iterated. Instead, I combine a new array that consists of three parts:
head - items before the modified item
the modified item
tail - items after the modified item
Here the example I've used in my code (NgRx, yet the machanism is the same for other Redux implementations):
// toggle done property: true to false, or false to true
function (state, action) {
const todos = state.todos;
const todoIdx = todos.findIndex(t => t.id === action.id);
const todoObj = todos[todoIdx];
const newTodoObj = { ...todoObj, done: !todoObj.done };
const head = todos.slice(0, todoIdx - 1);
const tail = todos.slice(todoIdx + 1);
const newTodos = [...head, newTodoObj, ...tail];
}

Pay attention to the data structure:
in a project I have data like this
state:{comments:{items:[{...},{...},{...},...]} and to update one item in items I do this
case actionTypes.UPDATE_COMMENT:
const indexComment = state.comments.items.findIndex(
(comment) => comment.id === action.payload.data.id,
);
return {
...state,
comments: {
...state.comments,
items: state.comments.items.map((el, index) =>
index === indexComment ? { ...el, ...action.payload.data } : el,
),
},
};

Note: in newer versions (#reduxjs/toolkit), Redux automatically detects changes in object, and you don't need to return a complete state :
/* reducer */
const slice = createSlice({
name: 'yourweirdobject',
initialState: { ... },
reducers: {
updateText(state, action) {
// updating one property will cause Redux to update views
// only depending on that property.
state.contents[action.payload.id].text = action.payload.text
},
...
}
})
/* store */
export const store = configureStore({
reducer: {
yourweirdobject: slice.reducer
}
})
This is how you should do now.

Updating nested data in redux store

What's the best/correct way to update a nested array of data in a store using redux?
My store looks like this:
{
items:{
1: {
id: 1,
key: "value",
links: [
{
id: 10001
data: "some more stuff"
},
...
]
},
...
}
}
I have a pair of asynchronous actions that updates the complete items object but I have another pair of actions that I want to update a specific links array.
My reducer currently looks like this but I'm not sure if this is the correct approach:
switch (action.type) {
case RESOURCE_TYPE_LINK_ADD_SUCCESS:
// TODO: check whether the following is acceptable or should we create a new one?
state.items[action.resourceTypeId].isSourceOf.push(action.resourceTypeLink);
return Object.assign({}, state, {
items: state.items,
});
}

Jonny's answer is correct (never mutate the state given to you!) but I wanted to add another point to it. If all your objects have IDs, it's generally a bad idea to keep the state shape nested.
This:
{
items: {
1: {
id: 1,
links: [{
id: 10001
}]
}
}
}
is a shape that is hard to update.
It doesn't have to be this way! You can instead store it like this:
{
items: {
1: {
id: 1,
links: [10001]
}
},
links: {
10001: {
id: 10001
}
}
}
This is much easier for update because there is just one canonical copy of any entity. If you need to let user “edit a link”, there is just one place where it needs to be updated—and it's completely independent of items or anything other referring to links.
To get your API responses into such a shape, you can use normalizr. Once your entities inside the server actions are normalized, you can write a simple reducer that merges them into the current state:
import merge from 'lodash/object/merge';
function entities(state = { items: {}, links: {} }, action) {
if (action.response && action.response.entities) {
return merge({}, state, action.response.entities);
}
return state;
}
Please see Redux real-world example for a demo of such approach.

React's update() immutability helper is a convenient way to create an updated version of a plain old JavaScript object without mutating it.
You give it the source object to be updated and an object describing paths to the pieces which need to be updated and changes that need to be made.
e.g., if an action had id and link properties and you wanted to push the link to an array of links in an item keyed with the id:
var update = require('react/lib/update')
// ...
return update(state, {
items: {
[action.id]: {
links: {$push: action.link}
}
}
})
(Example uses an ES6 computed property name for action.id)

Categories

Resources