Related
Can anyone tell me the difference between these? I started noticing some behaviours that i was not expecting.
let myObj = { _name:"Consala",
get name(){
return `Mr. ${this._name}` }}
Why does this require the this keyword because i thought functions have access to all variables surrounding them.
I explained this by saying that variables are different from properties and there is no variable called _name inside of the myObj just a property. Im not sure if this is correct though.
I tried to test this theory using this:
let test = "banana"
print(test) //prints banana
print(this.test) //prints undefined
this.test = "apple"
print(this.test) //prints apple
I thought this confirmed what i thought because when undefined was printed i explained it as there is no property called test on the global object showing me there is a difference between variables and properties.
But then i changed let to var and then print(this.test) also prints banana instead of undefined...
Whats going on here?
Im pretty confused but im thinking that when you use var you are setting a property to the object its in (which would explain why var has function scope right?) but then what happens when you use let?
**I hope people dont think of this as a low effort post because i have really been trying to figure this one out on my own rather than just refusing to think for myself. Cheers
The reason why var prints banana instead of undefined is because you have declared it outside of all functions so it takes global scope.
The scope of a variable declared with var is its current execution context and closures thereof, which is either the enclosing function and functions declared within it, or, for variables declared outside any function, global.
Reference: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Reference/Statements/var
On the other hand, let is block scoped so it gives you undefined
And to answer your question about why we need this, it is because the name getter function has no variable called _name in its scope.
Thus it needs this to indicate to it to use the object scope to look for the _name variable
this keyword is the most confusing keyword in JavaScript. It's not because it's kind of buggy or what but it's because developers think it will work in the same way as it does in other languages but that's not true.
this has dynamic scope. Dynamic scoping does not care how the code is written, but instead how it executes. So the value of this depends on how is it executed.
Talking about your first example
let myObj = { _name:"Consala",
get name(){
return `Mr. ${this._name}` }}
In this case, when you call that function you type myObj.name which binds myObj as this to name. So whenever you call a function using [Object Name].[function] you assign this object as the function's this.
Let's come to the second scenario. I assume you tried that in your browser.
In the case of Browser, this refers to window Object (Try console.log(this) ).
What happens there is when you declare a variable using let it doesn't add to Window object but when you declare it using var keyword, it adds to Window Object.
Try declaring a Variable using var and then do console.log(this). You will find that variable in Window Object but in case of a variable declared using let won't be there.
It may seem very trivial issue but very confusing and recurring for me. In some manuals for javascript or tutorials these terms are used alternately.
In others I found the explanation that we declare variables when we create them with var const let and we define variables, when we append some value/object to the declared variable as below:
var name; //declaring
name = 'Adam' //defining
var age = 'dead' //declaring + defining
Are there any approved and correct rules of using these two terms?
I'd say that "variable definition" is not a standard JavaScript term.
Functions (of all kinds) and object properties can get defined, but variables always get declared. This terminology might hint at the declarative nature of variables - a declaration always applies to the complete current scope, it's not an action that gets executed and does something.
var name is a declaration. var age = 'dead' is a declaration with an initialiser. name = 'Adam' is just an assignment. I'd guess that "defining" a variable refers to it no longer being undefined, so both an assignment statement or the initialiser of the declaration might do that. I'd rather speak of the initialisation of the variable, though.
var x is a declaration because you are not defining what value it holds but you are declaring its existence and the need for memory allocation.
var x = 1 is both declaration and definition but are separated with x being declared in the beginning while its definition comes at the line specified (variable assignments happen inline).
I see that you already understand the concept of hoisting but for those that don't, Javascript takes every variable and function declaration and brings it to the top (of its corresponding scope) then trickles down assigning them in order.
You seem to know most of this already though. Here's a great resource if you want some advanced, in-depth exploration. Yet I have a feeling you've been there before.
Javascript Garden
This question already has answers here:
What is the purpose of the var keyword and when should I use it (or omit it)?
(19 answers)
Closed 7 years ago.
Is "var" optional?
myObj = 1;
same as ?
var myObj = 1;
I found they both work from my test, I assume var is optional. Is that right?
They mean different things.
If you use var the variable is declared within the scope you are in (e.g. of the function). If you don't use var, the variable bubbles up through the layers of scope until it encounters a variable by the given name or the global object (window, if you are doing it in the browser), where it then attaches. It is then very similar to a global variable. However, it can still be deleted with delete (most likely by someone else's code who also failed to use var). If you use var in the global scope, the variable is truly global and cannot be deleted.
This is, in my opinion, one of the most dangerous issues with javascript, and should be deprecated, or at least raise warnings over warnings. The reason is, it's easy to forget var and have by accident a common variable name bound to the global object. This produces weird and difficult to debug behavior.
This is one of the tricky parts of Javascript, but also one of its core features. A variable declared with var "begins its life" right where you declare it. If you leave out the var, it's like you're talking about a variable that you have used before.
var foo = 'first time use';
foo = 'second time use';
With regards to scope, it is not true that variables automatically become global. Rather, Javascript will traverse up the scope chain to see if you have used the variable before. If it finds an instance of a variable of the same name used before, it'll use that and whatever scope it was declared in. If it doesn't encounter the variable anywhere it'll eventually hit the global object (window in a browser) and will attach the variable to it.
var foo = "I'm global";
var bar = "So am I";
function () {
var foo = "I'm local, the previous 'foo' didn't notice a thing";
var baz = "I'm local, too";
function () {
var foo = "I'm even more local, all three 'foos' have different values";
baz = "I just changed 'baz' one scope higher, but it's still not global";
bar = "I just changed the global 'bar' variable";
xyz = "I just created a new global variable";
}
}
This behavior is really powerful when used with nested functions and callbacks. Learning about what functions are and how scope works is the most important thing in Javascript.
Nope, they are not equivalent.
With myObj = 1; you are using a global variable.
The latter declaration create a variable local to the scope you are using.
Try the following code to understand the differences:
external = 5;
function firsttry() {
var external = 6;
alert("first Try: " + external);
}
function secondtry() {
external = 7;
alert("second Try: " + external);
}
alert(external); // Prints 5
firsttry(); // Prints 6
alert(external); // Prints 5
secondtry(); // Prints 7
alert(external); // Prints 7
The second function alters the value of the global variable "external", but the first function doesn't.
There's a bit more to it than just local vs global. Global variables created with var are different than those created without. Consider this:
var foo = 1; // declared properly
bar = 2; // implied global
window.baz = 3; // global via window object
Based on the answers so far, these global variables, foo, bar, and baz are all equivalent. This is not the case. Global variables made with var are (correctly) assigned the internal [[DontDelete]] property, such that they cannot be deleted.
delete foo; // false
delete bar; // true
delete baz; // true
foo; // 1
bar; // ReferenceError
baz; // ReferenceError
This is why you should always use var, even for global variables.
There's so much confusion around this subject, and none of the existing answers cover everything clearly and directly. Here are some examples with comments inline.
//this is a declaration
var foo;
//this is an assignment
bar = 3;
//this is a declaration and an assignment
var dual = 5;
A declaration sets a DontDelete flag. An assignment does not.
A declaration ties that variable to the current scope.
A variable assigned but not declared will look for a scope to attach itself to. That means it will traverse up the food-chain of scope until a variable with the same name is found. If none is found, it will be attached to the top-level scope (which is commonly referred to as global).
function example(){
//is a member of the scope defined by the function example
var foo;
//this function is also part of the scope of the function example
var bar = function(){
foo = 12; // traverses scope and assigns example.foo to 12
}
}
function something_different(){
foo = 15; // traverses scope and assigns global.foo to 15
}
For a very clear description of what is happening, this analysis of the delete function covers variable instantiation and assignment extensively.
var is optional. var puts a variable in local scope. If a variable is defined without var, it is in global scope and not deletable.
edit
I thought that the non-deletable part was true at some point in time with a certain environment. I must have dreamed it.
Check out this Fiddle: http://jsfiddle.net/GWr6Z/2/
function doMe(){
a = "123"; // will be global
var b = "321"; // local to doMe
alert("a:"+a+" -- b:"+b);
b = "something else"; // still local (not global)
alert("a:"+a+" -- b:"+b);
};
doMe()
alert("a:"+a+" -- b:"+b); // `b` will not be defined, check console.log
They are not the same.
Undeclared variable (without var) are treated as properties of the global object. (Usually the window object, unless you're in a with block)
Variables declared with var are normal local variables, and are not visible outside the function they're declared in. (Note that Javascript does not have block scope)
Update: ECMAScript 2015
let was introduced in ECMAScript 2015 to have block scope.
The var keyword in Javascript is there for a purpose.
If you declare a variable without the var keyword, like this:
myVar = 100;
It becomes a global variable that can be accessed from any part of your script. If you did not do it intentionally or are not aware of it, it can cause you pain if you re-use the variable name at another place in your javascript.
If you declare the variable with the var keyword, like this:
var myVar = 100;
It is local to the scope ({] - braces, function, file, depending on where you placed it).
This a safer way to treat variables. So unless you are doing it on purpose try to declare variable with the var keyword and not without.
Consider this question asked at StackOverflow today:
Simple Javascript question
A good test and a practical example is what happens in the above scenario...
The developer used the name of the JavaScript function in one of his variables.
What's the problem with the code?
The code only works the first time the user clicks the button.
What's the solution?
Add the var keyword before the variable name.
Var doesn't let you, the programmer, declare a variable because Javascript doesn't have variables. Javascript has objects. Var declares a name to an undefined object, explicitly. Assignment assigns a name as a handle to an object that has been given a value.
Using var tells the Javacript interpreter two things:
not to use delegation reverse traversal look up value for the name, instead use this one
not to delete the name
Omission of var tells the Javacript interpreter to use the first-found previous instance of an object with the same name.
Var as a keyword arose from a poor decision by the language designer much in the same way that Javascript as a name arose from a poor decision.
ps. Study the code examples above.
Everything about scope aside, they can be used differently.
console.out(var myObj=1);
//SyntaxError: Unexpected token var
console.out(myObj=1);
//1
Something something statement vs expression
No, it is not "required", but it might as well be as it can cause major issues down the line if you don't. Not defining a variable with var put that variable inside the scope of the part of the code it's in. If you don't then it isn't contained in that scope and can overwrite previously defined variables with the same name that are outside the scope of the function you are in.
I just found the answer from a forum referred by one of my colleague. If you declare a variable outside a function, it's always global. No matter if you use var keyword or not. But, if you declare the variable inside a function, it has a big difference. Inside a function, if you declare the variable using var keyword, it will be local, but if you declare the variable without var keyword, it will be global. It can overwrite your previously declared variables. - See more at: http://forum.webdeveloperszone.com/question/what-is-the-difference-between-using-var-keyword-or-not-using-var-during-variable-declaration/#sthash.xNnLrwc3.dpuf
This question already has answers here:
What is the purpose of the var keyword and when should I use it (or omit it)?
(19 answers)
Closed 7 years ago.
Is "var" optional?
myObj = 1;
same as ?
var myObj = 1;
I found they both work from my test, I assume var is optional. Is that right?
They mean different things.
If you use var the variable is declared within the scope you are in (e.g. of the function). If you don't use var, the variable bubbles up through the layers of scope until it encounters a variable by the given name or the global object (window, if you are doing it in the browser), where it then attaches. It is then very similar to a global variable. However, it can still be deleted with delete (most likely by someone else's code who also failed to use var). If you use var in the global scope, the variable is truly global and cannot be deleted.
This is, in my opinion, one of the most dangerous issues with javascript, and should be deprecated, or at least raise warnings over warnings. The reason is, it's easy to forget var and have by accident a common variable name bound to the global object. This produces weird and difficult to debug behavior.
This is one of the tricky parts of Javascript, but also one of its core features. A variable declared with var "begins its life" right where you declare it. If you leave out the var, it's like you're talking about a variable that you have used before.
var foo = 'first time use';
foo = 'second time use';
With regards to scope, it is not true that variables automatically become global. Rather, Javascript will traverse up the scope chain to see if you have used the variable before. If it finds an instance of a variable of the same name used before, it'll use that and whatever scope it was declared in. If it doesn't encounter the variable anywhere it'll eventually hit the global object (window in a browser) and will attach the variable to it.
var foo = "I'm global";
var bar = "So am I";
function () {
var foo = "I'm local, the previous 'foo' didn't notice a thing";
var baz = "I'm local, too";
function () {
var foo = "I'm even more local, all three 'foos' have different values";
baz = "I just changed 'baz' one scope higher, but it's still not global";
bar = "I just changed the global 'bar' variable";
xyz = "I just created a new global variable";
}
}
This behavior is really powerful when used with nested functions and callbacks. Learning about what functions are and how scope works is the most important thing in Javascript.
Nope, they are not equivalent.
With myObj = 1; you are using a global variable.
The latter declaration create a variable local to the scope you are using.
Try the following code to understand the differences:
external = 5;
function firsttry() {
var external = 6;
alert("first Try: " + external);
}
function secondtry() {
external = 7;
alert("second Try: " + external);
}
alert(external); // Prints 5
firsttry(); // Prints 6
alert(external); // Prints 5
secondtry(); // Prints 7
alert(external); // Prints 7
The second function alters the value of the global variable "external", but the first function doesn't.
There's a bit more to it than just local vs global. Global variables created with var are different than those created without. Consider this:
var foo = 1; // declared properly
bar = 2; // implied global
window.baz = 3; // global via window object
Based on the answers so far, these global variables, foo, bar, and baz are all equivalent. This is not the case. Global variables made with var are (correctly) assigned the internal [[DontDelete]] property, such that they cannot be deleted.
delete foo; // false
delete bar; // true
delete baz; // true
foo; // 1
bar; // ReferenceError
baz; // ReferenceError
This is why you should always use var, even for global variables.
There's so much confusion around this subject, and none of the existing answers cover everything clearly and directly. Here are some examples with comments inline.
//this is a declaration
var foo;
//this is an assignment
bar = 3;
//this is a declaration and an assignment
var dual = 5;
A declaration sets a DontDelete flag. An assignment does not.
A declaration ties that variable to the current scope.
A variable assigned but not declared will look for a scope to attach itself to. That means it will traverse up the food-chain of scope until a variable with the same name is found. If none is found, it will be attached to the top-level scope (which is commonly referred to as global).
function example(){
//is a member of the scope defined by the function example
var foo;
//this function is also part of the scope of the function example
var bar = function(){
foo = 12; // traverses scope and assigns example.foo to 12
}
}
function something_different(){
foo = 15; // traverses scope and assigns global.foo to 15
}
For a very clear description of what is happening, this analysis of the delete function covers variable instantiation and assignment extensively.
var is optional. var puts a variable in local scope. If a variable is defined without var, it is in global scope and not deletable.
edit
I thought that the non-deletable part was true at some point in time with a certain environment. I must have dreamed it.
Check out this Fiddle: http://jsfiddle.net/GWr6Z/2/
function doMe(){
a = "123"; // will be global
var b = "321"; // local to doMe
alert("a:"+a+" -- b:"+b);
b = "something else"; // still local (not global)
alert("a:"+a+" -- b:"+b);
};
doMe()
alert("a:"+a+" -- b:"+b); // `b` will not be defined, check console.log
They are not the same.
Undeclared variable (without var) are treated as properties of the global object. (Usually the window object, unless you're in a with block)
Variables declared with var are normal local variables, and are not visible outside the function they're declared in. (Note that Javascript does not have block scope)
Update: ECMAScript 2015
let was introduced in ECMAScript 2015 to have block scope.
The var keyword in Javascript is there for a purpose.
If you declare a variable without the var keyword, like this:
myVar = 100;
It becomes a global variable that can be accessed from any part of your script. If you did not do it intentionally or are not aware of it, it can cause you pain if you re-use the variable name at another place in your javascript.
If you declare the variable with the var keyword, like this:
var myVar = 100;
It is local to the scope ({] - braces, function, file, depending on where you placed it).
This a safer way to treat variables. So unless you are doing it on purpose try to declare variable with the var keyword and not without.
Consider this question asked at StackOverflow today:
Simple Javascript question
A good test and a practical example is what happens in the above scenario...
The developer used the name of the JavaScript function in one of his variables.
What's the problem with the code?
The code only works the first time the user clicks the button.
What's the solution?
Add the var keyword before the variable name.
Var doesn't let you, the programmer, declare a variable because Javascript doesn't have variables. Javascript has objects. Var declares a name to an undefined object, explicitly. Assignment assigns a name as a handle to an object that has been given a value.
Using var tells the Javacript interpreter two things:
not to use delegation reverse traversal look up value for the name, instead use this one
not to delete the name
Omission of var tells the Javacript interpreter to use the first-found previous instance of an object with the same name.
Var as a keyword arose from a poor decision by the language designer much in the same way that Javascript as a name arose from a poor decision.
ps. Study the code examples above.
Everything about scope aside, they can be used differently.
console.out(var myObj=1);
//SyntaxError: Unexpected token var
console.out(myObj=1);
//1
Something something statement vs expression
No, it is not "required", but it might as well be as it can cause major issues down the line if you don't. Not defining a variable with var put that variable inside the scope of the part of the code it's in. If you don't then it isn't contained in that scope and can overwrite previously defined variables with the same name that are outside the scope of the function you are in.
I just found the answer from a forum referred by one of my colleague. If you declare a variable outside a function, it's always global. No matter if you use var keyword or not. But, if you declare the variable inside a function, it has a big difference. Inside a function, if you declare the variable using var keyword, it will be local, but if you declare the variable without var keyword, it will be global. It can overwrite your previously declared variables. - See more at: http://forum.webdeveloperszone.com/question/what-is-the-difference-between-using-var-keyword-or-not-using-var-during-variable-declaration/#sthash.xNnLrwc3.dpuf
This question already has answers here:
What is the purpose of the var keyword and when should I use it (or omit it)?
(19 answers)
Closed 7 years ago.
Is "var" optional?
myObj = 1;
same as ?
var myObj = 1;
I found they both work from my test, I assume var is optional. Is that right?
They mean different things.
If you use var the variable is declared within the scope you are in (e.g. of the function). If you don't use var, the variable bubbles up through the layers of scope until it encounters a variable by the given name or the global object (window, if you are doing it in the browser), where it then attaches. It is then very similar to a global variable. However, it can still be deleted with delete (most likely by someone else's code who also failed to use var). If you use var in the global scope, the variable is truly global and cannot be deleted.
This is, in my opinion, one of the most dangerous issues with javascript, and should be deprecated, or at least raise warnings over warnings. The reason is, it's easy to forget var and have by accident a common variable name bound to the global object. This produces weird and difficult to debug behavior.
This is one of the tricky parts of Javascript, but also one of its core features. A variable declared with var "begins its life" right where you declare it. If you leave out the var, it's like you're talking about a variable that you have used before.
var foo = 'first time use';
foo = 'second time use';
With regards to scope, it is not true that variables automatically become global. Rather, Javascript will traverse up the scope chain to see if you have used the variable before. If it finds an instance of a variable of the same name used before, it'll use that and whatever scope it was declared in. If it doesn't encounter the variable anywhere it'll eventually hit the global object (window in a browser) and will attach the variable to it.
var foo = "I'm global";
var bar = "So am I";
function () {
var foo = "I'm local, the previous 'foo' didn't notice a thing";
var baz = "I'm local, too";
function () {
var foo = "I'm even more local, all three 'foos' have different values";
baz = "I just changed 'baz' one scope higher, but it's still not global";
bar = "I just changed the global 'bar' variable";
xyz = "I just created a new global variable";
}
}
This behavior is really powerful when used with nested functions and callbacks. Learning about what functions are and how scope works is the most important thing in Javascript.
Nope, they are not equivalent.
With myObj = 1; you are using a global variable.
The latter declaration create a variable local to the scope you are using.
Try the following code to understand the differences:
external = 5;
function firsttry() {
var external = 6;
alert("first Try: " + external);
}
function secondtry() {
external = 7;
alert("second Try: " + external);
}
alert(external); // Prints 5
firsttry(); // Prints 6
alert(external); // Prints 5
secondtry(); // Prints 7
alert(external); // Prints 7
The second function alters the value of the global variable "external", but the first function doesn't.
There's a bit more to it than just local vs global. Global variables created with var are different than those created without. Consider this:
var foo = 1; // declared properly
bar = 2; // implied global
window.baz = 3; // global via window object
Based on the answers so far, these global variables, foo, bar, and baz are all equivalent. This is not the case. Global variables made with var are (correctly) assigned the internal [[DontDelete]] property, such that they cannot be deleted.
delete foo; // false
delete bar; // true
delete baz; // true
foo; // 1
bar; // ReferenceError
baz; // ReferenceError
This is why you should always use var, even for global variables.
There's so much confusion around this subject, and none of the existing answers cover everything clearly and directly. Here are some examples with comments inline.
//this is a declaration
var foo;
//this is an assignment
bar = 3;
//this is a declaration and an assignment
var dual = 5;
A declaration sets a DontDelete flag. An assignment does not.
A declaration ties that variable to the current scope.
A variable assigned but not declared will look for a scope to attach itself to. That means it will traverse up the food-chain of scope until a variable with the same name is found. If none is found, it will be attached to the top-level scope (which is commonly referred to as global).
function example(){
//is a member of the scope defined by the function example
var foo;
//this function is also part of the scope of the function example
var bar = function(){
foo = 12; // traverses scope and assigns example.foo to 12
}
}
function something_different(){
foo = 15; // traverses scope and assigns global.foo to 15
}
For a very clear description of what is happening, this analysis of the delete function covers variable instantiation and assignment extensively.
var is optional. var puts a variable in local scope. If a variable is defined without var, it is in global scope and not deletable.
edit
I thought that the non-deletable part was true at some point in time with a certain environment. I must have dreamed it.
Check out this Fiddle: http://jsfiddle.net/GWr6Z/2/
function doMe(){
a = "123"; // will be global
var b = "321"; // local to doMe
alert("a:"+a+" -- b:"+b);
b = "something else"; // still local (not global)
alert("a:"+a+" -- b:"+b);
};
doMe()
alert("a:"+a+" -- b:"+b); // `b` will not be defined, check console.log
They are not the same.
Undeclared variable (without var) are treated as properties of the global object. (Usually the window object, unless you're in a with block)
Variables declared with var are normal local variables, and are not visible outside the function they're declared in. (Note that Javascript does not have block scope)
Update: ECMAScript 2015
let was introduced in ECMAScript 2015 to have block scope.
The var keyword in Javascript is there for a purpose.
If you declare a variable without the var keyword, like this:
myVar = 100;
It becomes a global variable that can be accessed from any part of your script. If you did not do it intentionally or are not aware of it, it can cause you pain if you re-use the variable name at another place in your javascript.
If you declare the variable with the var keyword, like this:
var myVar = 100;
It is local to the scope ({] - braces, function, file, depending on where you placed it).
This a safer way to treat variables. So unless you are doing it on purpose try to declare variable with the var keyword and not without.
Consider this question asked at StackOverflow today:
Simple Javascript question
A good test and a practical example is what happens in the above scenario...
The developer used the name of the JavaScript function in one of his variables.
What's the problem with the code?
The code only works the first time the user clicks the button.
What's the solution?
Add the var keyword before the variable name.
Var doesn't let you, the programmer, declare a variable because Javascript doesn't have variables. Javascript has objects. Var declares a name to an undefined object, explicitly. Assignment assigns a name as a handle to an object that has been given a value.
Using var tells the Javacript interpreter two things:
not to use delegation reverse traversal look up value for the name, instead use this one
not to delete the name
Omission of var tells the Javacript interpreter to use the first-found previous instance of an object with the same name.
Var as a keyword arose from a poor decision by the language designer much in the same way that Javascript as a name arose from a poor decision.
ps. Study the code examples above.
Everything about scope aside, they can be used differently.
console.out(var myObj=1);
//SyntaxError: Unexpected token var
console.out(myObj=1);
//1
Something something statement vs expression
No, it is not "required", but it might as well be as it can cause major issues down the line if you don't. Not defining a variable with var put that variable inside the scope of the part of the code it's in. If you don't then it isn't contained in that scope and can overwrite previously defined variables with the same name that are outside the scope of the function you are in.
I just found the answer from a forum referred by one of my colleague. If you declare a variable outside a function, it's always global. No matter if you use var keyword or not. But, if you declare the variable inside a function, it has a big difference. Inside a function, if you declare the variable using var keyword, it will be local, but if you declare the variable without var keyword, it will be global. It can overwrite your previously declared variables. - See more at: http://forum.webdeveloperszone.com/question/what-is-the-difference-between-using-var-keyword-or-not-using-var-during-variable-declaration/#sthash.xNnLrwc3.dpuf